DIY Stump Removal vs. Hiring a Professional in Ottawa
Every year, Ottawa homeowners go one of two routes with their stumps: rent a machine and try it themselves, or call a professional. Both can work — but they're not equal in every situation. Here's the honest breakdown.
Option 1: DIY Stump Grinding (Renting a Machine)
Most Ottawa equipment rental companies offer walk-behind stump grinders for around $250–$400 per day. On paper, this sounds like a great deal compared to hiring someone. In practice, there are several things to factor in.
What you're actually dealing with:
Rental stump grinders are typically smaller and less powerful than professional equipment. A rental machine that takes a professional 20 minutes to handle might take you 2–3 hours — and that's assuming the stump cooperates. Large stumps (over 18 inches), stumps near fences, or stumps with extensive root systems can be genuinely difficult with a rental unit.
The real costs of DIY:
- ✓Rental fee: $250–$400/day
- ✓Pickup and return (you need a truck or trailer): $80–$150 rental
- ✓Disposal of chips: your problem
- ✓Your time: 4–8 hours for a single medium stump, including pickup/return
- ✓Physical effort: stump grinders vibrate heavily and require constant operator control
- ✓Risk: hitting buried utilities, rocks, or roots causes machine damage — which you pay for
When DIY makes sense:
- ✓You have a small stump (under 10 inches) in an easy-to-access location
- ✓You already own or have access to a truck/trailer
- ✓You're comfortable operating heavy machinery
- ✓You have a full day free and enjoy this kind of work
Option 2: Hiring a Professional (Stickman Stump Removal)
At Stickman, we charge $75/ft of stump diameter for a single stump. A typical 12-inch (1-foot) stump costs $75. A 2-foot stump is $150. We're in and out in under an hour, the area is left clean, and you don't lift a finger.
What you get that you can't replicate with a rental:
- ✓Commercial-grade equipment: our grinders are significantly more powerful than rental units and cut through large or old stumps much faster
- ✓Experience: we know how to read a stump — where the main root plate is, how deep to go, how to avoid underground hazards
- ✓Full cleanup: chips raked, area levelled, ready to reseed
- ✓Insurance: if something goes wrong (a rock kicks up, an underground line wasn't marked), our liability coverage protects you
- ✓Speed: what takes a homeowner all day takes us 30–90 minutes
When hiring a professional is clearly the right call:
- ✓Stumps larger than 18 inches in diameter
- ✓Multiple stumps (our per-stump rate drops significantly)
- ✓Stumps near fences, foundations, or underground utilities
- ✓You value your time and don't want a physically exhausting weekend project
- ✓You want the job done right the first time
The Honest Bottom Line
For a single small stump in an open area, DIY is viable if you have the time and equipment access. For anything larger, multiple stumps, or stumps in tricky locations — professional grinding is faster, safer, and often not much more expensive once you factor in the real cost of renting.
If you're on the fence, call us for a free quote. You might be surprised how affordable professional service is compared to a full day of rental hassle.
📞 (613) 791-5366
✉️ Team@stickmanstumpremoval.ca
Ready to Remove Your Stump?
Free quotes. Same-week service across Ottawa and Eastern Ontario.